Friday July 8, 2011

HDR Tutorial Part 2

HDR Tutorial Navigation

You are on page 2 of 3.  You may go back to page 1 or jump to page 3.

Step 2: Get some equipment on the sly so your spouse does not ask too many questions

To create an HDR image, you need is a camera that can either:

  • Shoot in “Auto-bracketing mode” or “Auto-exposure mode”
  • or, shoot in RAW  (You can also create an HDR image out of a single RAW photo)

I talk about my HDR Camera equipment stuff here on the site, which is much more organized than the following Hawthornesque ramble. That equipment page lists out all kinds of nice recommendations if you are just getting started, or even looking for a little upgrade action.

Although you can make a decent HDR from a single RAW file, I recommend using a camera that has autobracketing. Autobracketing is the ability for your camera to take at least 3 pictures right after one another, each at different exposures. Sometimes it’s called “Exposure Bracketing”. If you are hunting around the menus on your camera now, just look for the words Autobracketing and perhaps some numbers like -2, 0, +2. If you have a DSLR camera, then you probably already have this ability.

What equipment do I have? People always ask me this, assuming, “Wow you must have a nice camera!” Well, I do have nice cameras (Nikon D3X and D3S as backup), but many of my best pictures were taken earlier with a lesser Nikons. I’m also not what I would consider a hardcore hardware guy – I use equipment to bend nature to my will, and I can do the same sort of work with just about any equipment. I’ve now got much higher-end equipment because I can now see the subtleties… somehow I can justify spending a lot of money for minor improvements in the shots. I justify many sketchy things in my life, but so do you, so why not add camera equipment to the heap of latent guilt?

I started with a Nikon D70. I then went on to the D2X before getting the D3X that now fills my life like a sweet song. In addition, I use four lenses. Again for details on the lenses, visit the HDR Camera section.

As for tripods, I have a giant one with a silky smooth rotating fat head. I used to have a tiny tripod, but it was too shaky. You gotta have a solid tripod. What? You don’t want to carry around a tripod? Comon… if you are going out to shoot beautiful pictures, you better get serious. Also, if you have it over your shoulder or carry it in an aggressive way, it makes an effective weapon. As you can see, I go all over the world, often into sketchy areas, and a big tripod is often an effective deterrent. I carry it so much, I am very good at flipping it around and whipping it around my body like ninja nunchaku.

The Before Shot The After Shot

HDR Tutorial

High Dynamic Range Tutorial

High Dynamic Range Tutorial

The Details at 100%. One surprising thing about HDR is its consistent ability to provide nice details at the pixel-by-pixel scale.

Step 3 – Look at the world in HDR

It is key to choose good HDR candidates. What I look for are extreme levels in light in a given scene.

Seeing the World Afresh

Consider those situations where there is extreme light and extreme dark, and how you are able to see it when you are there in real life, but you just know if you take a photo of it that it won’t come out right. Also, you normally would not dare to take a photo looking directly into the sun, right? Well with HDR you can… It will open up a new world to you… and the more HDR photography you shoot and process, the more you will learn to appreciate light and the world we live in.

In the last several years, I have taken note of how I see the world versus the way others see the world. It’s one of those age-old questions: “Is green to me the same as green to you? Maybe you just use the word green, but you actually see what I call yellow!” Well, this question also applies to HDR. Personally, I see the world in HDR, and that is how I record my memories. I find these photos entirely pleasing to admire. Now, I notice that about 80% of other people also feel the same way. This seems very consistent across audiences when I speak at universities, photo clubs, seminars, and the like. And, if you have read this far, then surely you see the world like me, and you are excited that you have finally found a window into the truth and future of recording imagery for the rest of your life.

Of course, this means 20% of people do not see the world like us. In fact, they absolutely despise HDR photography. Occasionally, you will get some old-school people that think post-processing is the work of the devil.  But, most often, I am convinced they simply don’t see the world like this. They see the world exactly how the camera spits out normal images. That’s okay… there is no convincing them… Hey, we can’t make everyone happy, can we?

A Good Example of Extreme Light Levels

Let’s work on a photo I did of the Space Shuttle during its final night on the launch pad. We’ll go through this guy step by step.

Now, this is a pretty good example of having to re-train your brain about light levels. Remember, when you are there, on the scene, your brain can handle it as your eye darts around the scene. Keep this in mind as you are around your house, in your neighborhood, driving around your city — you really are taking for granted how your brain is able to filter the light levels that your camera cannot.

Step 4 – Take your autobracketed pictures and prepare for the HDR

Set up your camera in Aperture Priority mode. This is important because you don’t want the multiple photos to have different areas of blur.

Turn on Autobracketing. If you have 3 pics in the autobracket, set it up at -2, 0, +2. On my Nikon D3x, I usually take 5 pics at -2, -1, 0, 1, +2. I’d prefer just to take 3 pics at -2, 0, and +2, but this camera only steps by 1. I think you will find this +2 to -2 range satisfactory for 95% of situations. An exception, for example, would be shooting the interior of a house that is extremely dark and there are windows where the outside is extremely bright.

Other best practices:

  • For 95% of situations, going from +2 to -2 is enough light range.
  • Shoot in RAW, if you can. JPG is okay, but RAW gives your more flexibility later in the processing. RAW photos contain a lot more light information than a JPEG. Please note that when processing in Photomatix later, the RAWs are no better than JPEGs.
  • Use a tripod, unless you have the steady arms of a late-model Terminator robot.
  • If you don’t use a tripod, it’s not a big problem, because Photomatix can align the images for you.

Below, you can see the five images from the Space Shuttle.

HDR Tutorial

The five images. These were shot with 5 different exposures from -2 to +2.

Step 5 – Using Photomatix Pro

Now it is time to fire up Photomatix and get crunk in the HDR house. Okay that was stupid. I never would say crunk in real life… so don’t think I am that sort of person.

Photomatix will take your photos and convert them into an HDR image. You can then tonemap the image and save it as a JPEG. I’ll take you through this process.

You can run Photomatix in a few ways:

  • To generate an single HDR from some autobraketed shots (most common for beginners and the bulk of this tutorial)
  • To do a huge batch of HDRs after you come back from a shoot
  • To convert a single RAW photo into an HDR

Let’s go over the first one in detail. When Photomatix is loaded up, you just see a menu. Note that I am using Photomatix 4.1 Beta, and new versions come out all the time. However, later iterations should still work within the margin of error of the following screenshots.

Note: You will see that I have 5 JPGs here. I used Lightroom to convert the 5 RAWS to 5 JPG. You can use Photomatix to open up the RAW photos as well, but Photomatix itself will do the conversion on its own. After speaking with the engineers at Photomatix, they tell me it is a little better to do the conversion on your own.

HDR Tutorial

After clicking "Load Bracket Photos", choose "Browse" to go find your photos.

HDR Tutorial

Choose the photos and then click "Load".

Choose the images you like then click OK. You will then see a second dialog that is below.  Here is an explanation of what is going on:

Notes:

  • If you feel like you had some camera shake, choose “Align Source Images”
  • If there was movement or “ghosting”, chose “Reduce ghosting artifacts”
  • This will take you to another screen where you can then select the area of the photo that has the ghosting.  After that, you can select which component photo to use instead of the ghost.
  • If you shot at a high ISO or anticipate a lot of noise, chose “Reduce noise”
  • If you have the sort of lens or situation that gives you annoying chromatic aberrations (those nasty purple and green outlines you see at 100% sometimes), then choose this option to help minimize those.
  • There are not many wrong choices you can make on this dialog, so don’t panic.

    Preprocess Photomatix

    Preprocessing options allow you to make a few choices that affect the overall processing of the images. No worries, there are no bad choices to make here!

    Click Preprocess and now your computer will churn like a farm of computers generating a single frame from a Pixar movie.  Note that if you checked any of the boxes above, this processing steps even longer.

    Every picture is different. There is no “right way” to set these sliders. There is certainly a “wrong” way to do it, though. I am sure you have seen lots of crappy HDR images. Below, I paste an example of how you can really make your image look too funkadelic. Funkadelic is cool if that is what you want or you have a lot of druggie friends that like laser light shows and your mind-bending HDRs, but most people don’t like them. Actually, please don’t look at my old work. It’s a little over-the-top too… I cringe when I think about it. Just look at the newer stuff. Thank you kindly.

    Actually, I keep my older stuff up there to illustrate how much progress you can make in such a short time.  I hope this is as inspirational for you as it is embarrassing to me.

    High Dynamic Range Tutorial

    Friends don't let friends do HDR on drugs.

    Above, you can see the options I selected. It’s way overdone. The key setting is in that “Lighting Adjustments” section. Just be careful. Please! For the sake of humanity.

    Below, you can see the default settings. Note that if you are afraid of all the sliders, you can just pick the pre-made thumbnails on the right, and you’ll be in business. The rest of the tutorial describes how I use the controls.

    High Dynamic Range Tutorial

    These are the default settings that appear in Photomatix. Since every photo is different, I advise getting to know and "playing" with the sliders.

    Now, it’s time to start making the adjustments that are good for this image in particular. Remember, none of these settings are cast in stone:

  • Strength – Keep it at 100%.  If it comes out too strong, you can always dial it back later in Photoshop, should you want to go into the Advanced steps.
  • Color Saturation – Keep it reasonable.  Don’t over-saturate your photo.  Again, each photo is different.  There is a difference between color that pops and color that bleeds too electric.  Remember, HDR is about light, not about over-saturation!
  • Luminosity – This is used for the “painterly effect”, let us say.  The further to the right, the less contrast will be in the photo.  If you find yourself with “Halo” problems in daylight shots, moving this to the far right will help.
  • Detail Contrast – A mysterious slider that helps the details and fluctuations in colors on the very small scale.  Like the others, play with this until it looks and feels right.  Generally, the more to the right, the more grungy and black-contrasty it becomes.
  • Lighting Adjustments – This is an important slider that effects the “HDRness” of the shot.  The more to the left, the more psychedelic.
  • White Point & Black Point – Be sure to pop the Black Point off the left side, where it rests by default.  Bringing a bit of black into the image will help the other colors resonate.  Adjust the White Point so that the bright parts of the image are not blown out.
  • All the other sliders?  They are interesting, but I honestly don’t use them much.  I won’t waste your valuable time by going into extreme descriptions of oft-ignored controls.
High Dynamic Range Tutorial Photo

I have used arrows here to point to the sliders I use the most often.

Once you have set everything up with the sliders, click Process and save the result.

You are Done!

You can make a case that you are all finished now! :)  Just getting to this point can make a tremendous difference in your photos.

Now, personally, there are more steps that I go through.  These are a series of advanced steps… sort of a master’s touch that borders on the obsessive.  I will also describe these on Page 3 – Advanced Steps, but know they are not necessary.

The next steps describe how to clean up more of the photo, reduce noise, and sharpen details.

Continue to Page 3 – Advanced Steps

Want to see all the steps I go through? Keep on movin’ along for Page 3.

A little Ad

Do you mind if I tell you about the 11+ hour video tutorial? If you want to watch me do this stuff, time and time again, this may be a great option for you… below is a little preview option. See more on the HDR Video Tutorial page!

Next Steps

Click here to Continue to Page 3.

About Me
  • Pingback: HDR Tutorial Part 3

  • Jil

    LOVING this. Bummed that my little nikon d50 wont do autobracketing, but about to spend some student loan funds to upgrade ;)

  • Diane

    @Jill, the D50 has auto-bracketing for 3 exposures – pages 93-94 of your manual.

  • Skyler

    LOL – Friends don’t let friends do HDR on Drugs. Classic. I love it. But that certainly limits my time to experiment with HDR:)~

  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/nadinfinityphotography/ Terry

    Thanks for sharing. Your tutorial was brilliant and it made things so easy. My first attempts were really over saturated but after follwing your kind advice it looks like I’ve been doing this for years:)
    Wicked sense of humour too and it helps that you’re a gamer!
    Thanks again.
    Cheers
    nadinfinity

  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/mchaconcr/ mchaconcr

    I have a Nikon D60…. great camera…. but no option for bracketing neither cable-shutter!!! So… probably the worst decision for HDR!

  • MilesToEmpty

    I cry that page 3 doesnt work!

  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/rolli22 Nathan Yakobovitch

    Hello Trey

    Needless to say how impressed I am with your pictures, HDRs and humorous approach as well as with the tutorials. Just discovered you and I am about to offer my priceless friendship to you on flickr :-) .
    And if you ever wish to photograph the beauties of Israel – let me know. I am here to help!

    Nathan

  • http://Flickr Joyce Homan

    Thank you so much for sharing. I don’t have any of the software needed for the HDR editing but that does not mean I don’t know a good photogrpah when I see one. Your work is amazing. David Hill must be worried.;-)

  • http://seawhisper.deviantart.com Paula

    Omg “ninja nunchaku”!!! I could just read your articles to find such pearls! :)

  • Brandon

    Brilliant tutorial! Your humorous approach to it made it a fantastic read.

    I have a quick question though. Can the auto-bracketing feature not be simulated by taking a single RAW shot then adjusting the EV with an application before bringing it into Photomatix? This should also negate the need for a tripod. Are there any down sides to this method?

    Thanks again for a great read.

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com Stuck In Customs

    Hehe thanks… I always wonder why ppl leave comments on page 2 of 3 of the tutorial! No problem… to answer your question, Brandon – no that does not really work. That is the same thing as opening the RAW file itself in Photomatix — it just takes a lot more time!

  • http://overridemofo.blogspot.com Andy Kow

    I love this tutorial! Learned extra steps from it. Thanks so much for making it. :)

  • Alejandro de Leon

    i cant open JPEG image (the HDR from photomatix) i cant open it in the RAW window in photoshop, can anyone help me?¿

  • http://www.aliceintaraminunilor.wordpress.com alice

    well, maybe you can’t open jpeg’s in the raw window. maybe the raw window is just for raw…
    did anyone think of that?

  • steve
  • Marcos

    Real cool tutorial!
    Have a question:
    My Sony DSC-H50, which isn’t DSLR but has autobracketing anyway, only takes shots within -1 to +1 EV range. It has, though, a remote control which I (guess I) can use to adjust the EV to -2 , then 0 and +2 manually, without touching the camera. Do you think that this would work, even if only in very stable scenes since it would take some time between each shot?

  • carmel

    Does a Nikon D90 has auto bracketing?

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com Stuck In Customs

    Marcos – I think that would work

    Carmel – I believe so… just check the features to double-check

  • Jake L

    I just stumbled onto this site while looking for HDR info, and wow: AWESOME! This place is literally a gold mine for aspiring photographers like myself. While I’m here, I’m too curious not asking: Do you (the blog writer, or anybody) prefer the D40 over the Canon 450D Xsi? And why? I have an underlying feeling in the pit of my stomach that I made the wrong choice by going with the XSi, but I haven’t found any good reason.

  • Val

    Answer to Jake L -
    It’s really not the camera… it’s the processing that matters. Any cam you have will do.. later you can find your taste in cameras as you work with them. A flickr friend has both the D40x and the XTi and he said the XTi is way more camera than his D40x… and he does great HDR with both but I think there is much more detail from his XTi.

  • http://myimagelife.wordpress.com/ Obi

    Great tutorial. Really interesting stuff to get into.

  • Laura

    Does the Nikon D60 have autobracketing? How do you HDR objects that are moving when your suppose to take more than one of the same picture at least 3 times?

  • David

    Nice prose Trey; funny and informative. Ive always felt like the presence of a camera ruins a good photo, but Im inspired to try HDR again now.
    Thanks!
    David

  • Pingback: tokyololas » HDR/Tonemapping for Black & White Photos

  • Courtney

    Hi! I Love your work! I’m wondering if you can help me though. I seem to be doing everything right – except getting great focus for all 5 shots! What do you do prior to shutter release to get such stunning photos?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Trey-Ratcliff/502475833 Trey Ratcliff

    Thanks everyone.

    Well… I would set it in ap pri mode and be sure you leave it in autofocus …. keep your F stop at a high number if you want to keep everything in focus.

  • Hans

    Brilliant tutorial, added a new dimension to my Canon 400D. I’ve tinkered with HDR for some time but this has helped me better understand what I was actually doing…AND there is the added bonus that I have learned to stride blatantly into the seedy part of town confident with my trusty Manfrotto slung over my shoulder..!!

  • Dave

    Very cool shots! So how do you give the HDR treatment to a single exposure when multiples are not possible??

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com Stuck In Customs

    Thanks all…

    Dave – that is on page 3 of the tutorial – you are almost there!

  • Jordan

    Just stumbled upon this website and technique and am absolutely enthralled! I am a fairly new to the realms of DSLRs and am finding my experience with them to be absolutely incredible, however, looking at the results you have achieved (of course with a very good eye for composition and all the rest) it has opened up a wealth of ideas for me.

    I currently own the Nikon D60. I am told that this does not feature an auto-bracketing function/mode. Is there any other way to automate or manually (easily) capture photographs at different levels of exposure?

    Thanks in advance

  • Boogaloo Timmy

    I know this was a few months ago now but in response to your response to Brandon i would say that you’re wrong. Adjusting the image exposure in RAW from a single shot and saving as a set of jpegs has completely different results to just opening a single RAW in Photomatix and gives excellent results. You have a lot more control for starters over the contrast and saturation and i’ve found that the more jpegs you create and the wider the range of exposures the better.

    Another great thing about it is that you can easily convert your photo into B+W and stick those into photomatix. And the results are great! It just adds a whole new layer of creativity that putting it straight into photomatix cuts out. Sure it’s easier to just drag and drop the RAW into ‘matix but the results are a little flat in comparison.

    Hope youre not offended by this!

    Tim

  • nodapic

    ninja nunchaku… nice. very nice. :)

  • Rey

    Trey, thanks very much for sharing your technique. I have been trying to learn HDR but no other sites have successfully outlined the technique as simple as you have.
    Just one quick question for you or for anyone reading this. What is your technique for setting up auto-bracketing for low light conditions? For example your Times Square picture were all taken at different shutter speeds and it contains some moving objects as well. Given that the picture were taken at night time, I would think that people in the picture would have moved slightly from the moment you took the 1st picture and the 5th picture, resulting in a blurry/ghosting effect. If the pictures are combined/aligned together, the moving object would be out of alignment, wouldn’t it?

    Once again, thanks very much for helping.

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com Stuck In Customs

    Thanks all

    Jordan – that camera still shoots RAW – that’s your best bet.

    Rey – yes some of the objects did get out of alignment – but that is why I went to remix with the original raw to clean it up. That make sense?

  • http://www.carlobiondi.com Carlo Biondi

    Hi Trey,
    your tutorial on HDR is nothing short of a revelation!!! Ken Rockwell refers to your site as yhe first HDR site he actually likes.
    So I purchased photomatix last night, went shooting before dinner (I live in the center of paris) and got amazing results!!!

    For those of you who have photoshop elements, I discovered there is a way to simulate a layer mask, it is widely documented on the internet.

    Many thanks and keep up the good work!

    Carlo

    Many thanks and keep up the great work

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Trey-Ratcliff/502475833 Trey Ratcliff

    Thanks Carlo – that is good to know about Elements – I get that a lot.

    And btw yall – I always wonder why people leave comments on Page 2 instead of Page 3 of the tutorial ? Maybe it is not obvious there is another page?

  • http://Chesterclose2(flickr) Steve O’Brien

    Great tips here ho I use a Canon 50d but some guy above has a D60 I had some good HDR images you can use in HDR work results from this camera you take the shot and immediately copy low normaal and high in the camera then you have more than one image to use in your HDR programme

  • Barrington

    Hi i’m using a imac can i up load from iphoto?

  • Roman

    Are you using the Nikon Capture NX software? I find that it does a better job of converting nef files into jpg than Adobe software does. Not to mention it is much easier to make minor image adjustments in it.

  • Rachelle

    I hope to upgrade my camera eventually but right now I have a camera that will do auto bracketing OR RAW photos but won’t do them together. It is quite annoying. I’m brand new at HDR. Which would you suggest I do: auto bracketing with JPG files or one RAW file?

  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/honeyjar/ Simone

    I notice you don’t speak about distortion, which might be a pain for people (like me) who like to use general purpose zoom lenses.
    Right after exporting to jpeg you will surely enjoy some aoutomated tools like ptlens ( http://epaperpress.com/ptlens/ ) to do the work for you. It’s very cheap and I really like it

  • http://link Pol34

    As far as the public option versus a price ceiling goes, the public option is probably more politically feasible. ,

  • Perry Bullard

    It was certainly my lucky day when I discovered this site. I had been playing around with HDR using Photomatix and was never really pleased with the final results. Then Trey introduced me to Lucisart….it really blew my mind. That is definitely a secret weapon that I don’t reveal to anyone. I have all the programs that Trey uses..Lightroom..PS CS4 extended..Imagenomic (great great program) and about three or four others. I use an Olympus E-3 that has 5 shot bracketing with +2 -2 exposure.

    Question. At what stage do you do your noise removal? Will it affect the color shift if it’s done in the mid stages?

    BTW..you live in Austin and I’m just down the road in San Antonio. Thanks for a great tutorial.

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com Stuck In Customs

    Thanks for the note :)

    Perry – I usually do noise reduction just about right away – especially before sharpening – the sharpening can do crazy things to the noise!

  • Perry Bullard

    Trey,
    I first learned of HDR abot two years ago in the German magazine der Spiegel, of which I am a contributing editor, and had no idea how it worked. My German born wife of 50 years discovered your website and turned me on to it. She’s into to PPS and shares PPS’ from around the world with me. I’m amazed at how frequently your photos turn up in those presentations…especially the shaggy pony,

    I’m a little confused about one step in your tutorial..

    “What I am going to do is select my favorite of the Original shots, and adjust the sliders so that it looks as close as possible to the Photomatix result.”

    Can you elaborate a bit on that step please.

    I recently picked up a tip for shooting panoramas. I had always shot in the horizontal and or course a lot of the picture was lost when it was cropped. Now I shoot in the vertical and with my f-2.8 12-60 lens I get very nice dimensions top and bottom.

    My next project it to shoot HDR panoramas in the vertical. Can you envision any problems using this technique?

    Thanks

    Perry

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com Stuck In Customs

    Thanks – btw – why are people leaving comments on page 2 rather than the last page? I don’t know.

    By that step, I am talking about the RAW IMporter. That is, you should see that Raw importer when bringing in your photos – adjust the sliders in there to make it as HDR-like as possible (fill light and contrast help)

  • Pingback: HDR Tutorial | 5ii???????

  • Michael Griffin

    Hey I was wondering something while I was reading this. Why are we playing around with lossy jpegs? Is it possible to keep it lossless by using a tiff, targa, or png? Wouldn’t that be for the best as we would not loose any information? Please let me know your thoughts on this…

  • Pingback: Too Much Glass » Blog Archive » The Inevitable

  • Pingback: HDR « Dónal Connolly

  • Allan D.

    Re. “autobracketing” You don’t need it. Use a tripod and use the exposure compensating function. If you don’t have that, take if out of automatic exposure and change your aperture or shutter speed. Don’t have a remote release, use the self timer. Don’t let your equipment stop you from trying something. People… remember film and hand exposure meters? How about sunny 16?

  • http://graywolf.dotphoto.com Julie B

    Trey, they leave comments because they can…. :) Nice tutorial BTW…now on to page three….

  • http://cchapin.blogspot.com/ Chip Chapin

    The PhotoShop cleanup is great. These are exactly the problems I have with my HDR images after Photomatix: weird ghost artifacts and sick-looking sky. Thank you so much!

  • John Y.

    Trey,
    Great article, and thank you for sharing with us! I have a few questions regarding raw file conversion:
    1. My D80 can save both jpeg and NEF files. I noticed you convert raw to jpeg in LR first, and then open them in photomatix. Is there an advantage using LR or other raw converter than using the jpeg files directly from the camera?
    2. When you convert raw in LR, do you apply the same setting to all 5 bracketed photos? or do you optimize them individually?
    Thank you!

  • Pingback: Introduzione all’HDR per chi ancora non lo conoscesse! « livingkrakow

  • Luke S

    When exporting to photomatix do you use sRGB or aRGB? Also why don’t you use 16-bit TIFF instead of 8-bit JPEG?

    Thanks!

  • Steven

    When you shoot people do they have to be still in an hdr shot? How do you not get any blur on your subject?

  • http://www.photobuzz.org Jen Weiss

    Wow this is amazing tutorial, your skills are incredible thank you for sharing,

    Jen

  • Marco

    Re: why are people leaving comments on page 2 rather than the last page?

    I’m having problems getting to the 3rd page of the tutorial. I get a blank page. I hope this helps. Also I didn’t get my feeds yesterday and the day before yesterday!
    First time that happens.
    Thanks a lot for everything!

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com Stuck In Customs

    Thanks!

    Well – we are moving servers – you just caught us in a bad hour – working on it ! :)

  • Olivia

    Hello! Page 3 is still not working…still waiting for the juicy part…

  • tree

    The link to the last page is not working…..that’s why people are podting on this page.

  • http://melodyg.com.au Melody

    Hey there!

    It’s 11th May 2010 and i can’t seem to access your 3rd page! You can’t leave me hnaging! LOL

  • ZoOlOoK

    Same as above. Unable to open the last and most promising page of the tutorial.

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com Stuck In Customs

    Part 3 is fixed now! :)

  • peter

    When are you going to introduce Photomatix for Nikon Capture NX?
    Regards, peter

  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/nathanwhite Nathan White

    Trey, do you apply individual develop settings to the bracketed set of shots before your export them as JPEG’s in Lightroom, or do you simply export ‘as taken’? i.e. you’ve simply chosen one of the camera profiles in Lightroom?

    Thanks for all your very interesting opinions and thoughts on the world of light and the way we see it, it has certainly made me look at things from a different perspective.

    Nathan.

  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/light487/ light487

    Ok, so I got myself the trial copy of Photomatix Pro and went photo-snapping to grab some RAW format photos to try it out with. I am using a Rixoh GX200 which does have auto-bracketing but unfortunately (and even more unfortunately because I didn’t realise till I got home after a whole day of shooting) it only autobrackets in 0.5 increments. I realised later, after re-reading the basic tutorial in Photomatix that I need to have at least +/- 2.0. So my photos don’t really change much at all from the original. I get a little bit of a change but not the noticeable and impressive results you have in your examples.

    However, this has given me a lesson in HDR by making mistakes. I need to know more about how to take the original images. How to choose which exposure setting for each of the 3 to 5 photos, at what time of day is it best to take the scenes (harsh light, soft light etc).. that kind of thing.

    I’m also a little unsure which exposure point of reference I should be using.. I mean should I be taking the light reading from the brightest part of the photo? (ie. if there are two sides to a building and there is a light side and dark shadowed side, which side should I be aiming to have as the main/middle exposure side)..

    I am thinking strongly of buying your book but if I can get just one picture to work once, I am willing to fork out the cash for the book, the full version of the software etc.. I’m just not sure if my camera is capable, within reason, to do this kind of thing. I mean.. every camera with the ability to lock apeture and manually change the exposure can do it.. but I’m sure that some are better suited to it. For example, the Ricoh GX200 is prone to noise at higher ISO’s..

    I’m new to the technical world of photography and could benefit from a bit of a helping hand. Thanks for the tutorial but I need a little more info.. :)

  • http://foomandoonian.net/ Foomandoonian

    “You can use Photomatix to open up the RAW photos as well, but Photomatix itself will do the conversion on its own. After speaking with the engineers at Photomatix, they tell me it is a little better to do the conversion on your own.”

    This strikes me as a bit odd. Since a RAW file contains enough data to make pretty good HDR pictures from a single shot, I’d have thought using 3+ RAW files would give far superior results to using 3+ JPEGS. Does anyone know why this isn’t the case?

  • Alexander

    I just bought my first camera d70s used. I have spent the better part of last week running around with it. Today I found your site and have just spent 6 hours creating some of my first HDR images.
    Also ya a tripod would be good, I made the moon look like some deformed bubble.

  • http://twitter.com/antovimal Anto Vimal Ratharaj

    Its real smoothie to HDR . Thanks!!

  • George E

    So I’m confused do I need to take five Pics at -2 -1 0 1 2 or do I need just three at -2 0 2? Or is it up to me?

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com Stuck In Customs

    Thanks all — three shots is just fine btw

  • Val

    Outstanding! Would you consider doing your tutorial as a video / youtube format?

    Thank you

  • Leo

    i was looking for something on photography on youtube and clicked on a video where you talked about HRD photography and as you said in the beginning of the video you will end up liking this and you man i really like it now
    i bought photomatix pro3 and i already have photoshop CS4 so i am really excited to get started !
    the tutorials are outstanding! plus helpful and are very enjoyable!! =]
    i plan on buying your book soon _ thanks_
    its people like you, who help the world be a better place by contributing you knowledge to others !

  • Lois Hild

    I have heard that the new PS CS5 has HDR processing features. Have you tried it? I will be getting CS5 Master Suite in a couple of weeks and was wondering if with this new PS feature I would still need Photomatix Pro. Any thoughts?

  • Lois Hild

    @ George E- Just to clear it up. Nikon bracketing feature doesn’t allow stop increments of 2, 1 is the largest you can get. In order to get the +2 and -2 exposures you have to take five total pics, discarding the +1 and -1. They were just stepping stones to get where you wanted to go. Hope that helps.

  • http://www.kennethphotography.com Kenneth

    Thanks for the tutorial! I just came back to this tutorial to review some of your explanations on what the various PhotoMatix settings are supposed to do, and my HDR photos are better (and less tacky-looking) for it. =]

  • http://www.kennethphotography.com Kenneth

    Another thing I wanted to note for people trying out HDR in extreme lighting environments — be sure you’re really getting a full range of exposures. One set of HDR photos I recently shot featured a giant window smack in the middle of the frame. Due to my metering mode, the camera suggested a shutter speed that was “correct” for properly exposing the bright light streaming in through the window, but would cause everything else in the frame to be very dark. As a result, even when I took 7 bracketed exposures, 6 of them ended up being extremely dark, and only the longest exposure had any degree of usable detail for the shadow areas of the image. Main lesson learned — check your shots to make sure you have a bracketed set that’s usable! If not, meter your exposure based on something more neutrally lit in your image first and use that shutter speed for the “middle” exposure of the bracketed set.

  • Pingback: T2i 550D HDR Tutorial Using PhotoMatix 4.0Beta

  • http://gypsychicktravels.com Shauna

    This is incredible information, thank you so much!
    I’m an amateur travel photographer. I got my first SLR, Nikon D60 with the 18-200 mm lens. I’ve been slogging away with Elements with my 15,000 photos… ugh. But you have inspired me with new potential. I had no idea HRD existed…I thought it was some photo black-magic secret that made these shots possible :) You have also sold me on the tripod :)

    This will be no doubt a site that I refer to again and again.

    Thanks for sharing :)

    Shauna

  • Zuska Madar

    I love this tutorial, helped a ton and loooove your humor,makes me laugh out loud.

  • http://www.internationalwed.com www.internationalwed.com

    Tank you, brllant tutorial! I’m a italian photographer, i think your tutorial is very useful for my photos!

  • http://www.hcpl.net Barbara Mitchell

    Hello Trey,
    I love your tutorial! Thanks. I teach a free basic Digital Photography class here at our public library and run four PowerPoints from hell to illustrate. I just copied your “Screenshot from Lightroom” to illustrate bracketing. Of course I cited you–I’m a librarian–but I want to thank you for working within the Creative Commons. Confident, creative, progressive people do that…

    I love HDR photographs, where photography kisses art…

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com Stuck In Customs

    hehe thanks Barbara – very nice of you… enjoy! Sweet creative commons…

  • http://www.theilluminatedphotographer.com shean

    Your photography and tutorial has been so very, very inspirational and has rekindled my love for photography. I am or should I say was a very ardent amateur photographer. Though I love it and have thrown in quite a few bucks into it I was in a period of absolute sloth when it came to my hobby because I had run out of inspiration and subject matter.
    You have opened my eyes again. I thank you from the bottom of my heart for that. Also for the promo code which saved me 20+ Canadian $$.
    I have always wanted to epublish my attempts at photography for friends and family. With your permission I would love to quote your take on HDR photography. I get quite sick and tired of the the lay view of digital darkroom work. I think you put into words what I couldn’t say without loosing my cool.
    Thank you once again.
    p.s- As of now my wife is quite annoyed that I’m still in my pj’s and on the MAC …. goooo PMatix !!!!!

  • Pingback: HDR tutorial (for Photography) « 156wzhang

  • Rosco

    Thanks for the great tutorial. Your images are fantastic. I’ve been watching you on Mostly Photo as well. Doing a great job. I am having really bad pixelization when I zoom in on the final image. I don’t know if it is because of the conversion to the jpeg or not. I don’t see it in the raw file. What settings do you use in Lightroom when exporting the jpeg’s to Photomatix? What should the resolution be set at? Thanks for your help.

  • Pingback: HDR系列(4):“正规流”的HDR处理:包围曝光(上) | HDR爱好者-High Dynamic Range

  • Antonio Ramirez

    hey trey..
    i have photomatix problems..:(
    i downloaded a photomatix pro 4.0.2 (32 bits) on my laptop..
    and a photomatix 3.2 (32 bits) also on my laptop..
    but i cant seem to find the same presets as shown in your screen shots..
    what version of photomatix did you used?..

  • Steve Loy

    Trey, Great shot of the Stanford Church! I just finished an HDR of Hoover Tower, thought you might like to see it. I would love to send it to you.

  • Pingback: Cherry Blossom Blizzard at Shrine ~ JapanDave.com

  • http://webshots.com/2cqql Gary

    Trey,
    Great stuff…I am hooked!! BTW 1st got to know you on TWIT/mostlyphoto with LePorte.

  • irfan

    Newbie with photoshop here.

    How do i import the pictures after i complete the processing in photomatix? I use photoshop cs5 and i’m unable to import. I tried click dragging the images and they all open up separately.

  • Jason

    Trey,

    I notice you take a lot of pictures that have some sort of movement in them like the woman walking on the beach into the water. Other photos (like the photo of the pier) don’t really have much movement except the waves hitting the shore. The one thing that has really been bugging me is how do you take multiple shots (like of the ocean) and combine them into one without messing up the water or some of the other moving objects. I know you can shoot in RAW and compose multiple pictures out of that, but a lot of pictures that I thought you would have done in RAW, you list as being a combination of 6 or 7 pictures. How do you do it?

  • Rick Probst

    Excellent. You asked for typos… You said know know but meant now you know. See below… So now you know.

    Now, personally, there are more steps that I go through. These are a series of advanced steps… sort of a master’s touch that borders on the obsessive. I will also describe these on Page 3 – Advanced Steps, but know know they are not necessary.

    You inspired me into HDR. Thanks! I would like to attend a seminar if you ever offer one again.

    I am 30 days into a one year project. I’m going to publish a book on one specific town. All HDR. 4 Seasons of the place I am photographing.

  • Gary Pope

    I am delighted to see you dissing your earlier attempts at HDR, which I refer to as the “HDR Effect”. Or Saturday morning cartoons. I have in the past done all of my HDR edits using Layers in Photoshop, manually creating my HDR images using layer masks. They, in my opinion, were much better than anything I had tried using HDR software, including early versions of Photomatix. However, I have lately been using Photoshop CS5 to create them, with guidance from Scott Kelby, and they work great for most of my work. Your work exemplifies what I have been trying to achieve since I first learned about HDR techniques. I am greatly enjoying this tutorial.

  • Theodor Tauber

    I want to remark:

    1) Using “Align your sources” button will create a new picture different in sizes from the original pictures used, so you will have problems while using Photoshop to correct different problems of the new picture.

    2) There are also other methods to play with light and shadows, not only HDR. Using the blending modes of Photoshop you can achieve nice results too.

  • David Roche

    Trey,

    Thanks for this guide. Your photos are inspiring me to take more pictures, and play with HDR for more shots.

    I’m surprised that you convert to jpg before importing to Photomatix. I would think that you’d want to do HDR on a lossless file format. When exporting the 5 JPEG images, the JPEG algorithm will be run on each image independently. Since JPEG throws out info that it thinks we can’t “see”, it will end up losing data in parts of the image that photomatix may try to match with other images. For example, in the underexposed shot, some dark leaves may end up blurred by jpeg, but photmatix wants to match this frame with the light colored leaves from the +0 or +2 shot. It seems that the resultant HDR image will be blurrier than if you work with lossless photos? I know that the Lightroom Photomatix plugin converts to tiff files before importing to Photomatix. Your advice to use the Adobe converter rather than Photomatix’s is good, but you want your intermediary file format to be TIFF for maximum sharpness in the HRD image.

  • Stephen Clarke

    David,
    If you set your jpeg compression to highest quality (ie; no compression), the resultant jpeg images are in fact lossless jpegs. As a result there is no loss of image quality. Also, Photomatix works with jpegs as temporary working files anyway. Thus when you are working in Photomatix it is still manipulating jpegs of your images in the background… whether you like it or not.
    -Steve

  • Lloyd Morley

    How do you deal with subject movement.

  • http://www.emrsavljenje.com Dijeta

    Hi there, You have done an incredible job. I’ll definitely digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I am sure they will be benefited from this site.

  • http://oxforddahayat.blogspot.com Marla

    Hi Trey,

    I am a newer and am grateful for your sharing here. Thank you.
    Well, I have tried Multiple Exposure for the first time in my life. I have got D90 – I love it. :)
    Anyway, my problem is that I can’t have 5 photos like you had above.
    When I shoot at 0 , +1 and +2, there is no problem. I have my photos, nice and clean. Yet, when I shoot at -2 or -1, they disappear after a second. :(
    I am sure I just need to change a detail in settings but as I said I am a newer. Can you tell me what to do, please?
    I am begging you. :)

    Greetings

  • Luke Lakatosh

    Hi everyone,

    We’re having a major spam problem on this page to the tune of about 100 posts a day, so we’re turning off comments here. If you want to leave a comment, head to page 1 or 3.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FQOH5SPAJ5OJVDS4TV4RBAYJNY allanjlansangan

    why was there no comment as to what adjustments are made in the Lightroom (RAW file) before converting it to jpeg for photomatix?

  • Anonymous

    Trey, thank you for sharing so willing.  I know you are blessed because you do.  I was a hardcore film photograher and only went digital due to a trip to Costa Rica…didn’t want to haul all of that film.  ;)   But I have been so afraid of the technical side of HDR and how it all worked.  It all seemed so complicated.   You have given me the spring board to jump in.  Thank you. 

    Quick question.  I can’t find if you shoot in raw or jpg, or both.  With the higher end Nikkons I know you have many options.  I happen to have a Nikkon D80.  I never shoot video so wasn’t interested in the D90.  And when my ship comes in I will up grade to a DX of some kind.

    Blessings,
    Daphne

  • http://www.stuckincustoms.com/ Luke Lakatosh (SIC Support)

    Hi Daphne,

    I’ll field this one for Trey.  Trey shoots in Nikon’s NEF raw format.  I believe the shots from Burning Man (where he usually uses a different camera) might be in JPG.